Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pasta With Butter Only
Lasagna
Ham & Cheese
Meatball Sub
About
CJ's Italian Restaurant
Welcome to CJ's Italian Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled at 405 Mallery St, St Simons Island, GA 31522. This charming eatery has quickly earned a reputation as one of the must-visit spots on the island, drawing locals and tourists alike with its inviting atmosphere and delectable Italian cuisine.
One of the highlights of CJ's is its selection of hearty salads, including the vibrant Antipasto and refreshing Greek Salad, both complemented by homemade bread and tangy marinara sauce. This attention to detail in every dish elevates the experience, making each meal feel special.
The real star, however, is undoubtedly the pizza. Customers rave about the deep dish pizza, which has a loyal following for its airy, crunchy edges and piled-high toppings. As one enthusiastic patron put it, "the deep dish style... is perfection!" This sentiment is echoed by many, solidifying CJ's as the go-to place for pizza lovers on the island. Whether you prefer the classic flavors or are feeling adventurous with their build-your-own pasta options, every dish is crafted with care and passion.
In addition to their pizza, you can’t go wrong with their mouth-watering appetizers. The made-from-scratch meatballs and cheesy breadsticks pair perfectly with the fresh marinara sauce, setting the tone for a delightful meal. And let's not forget the sandwiches—each served on a fresh homemade hoagie roll and bursting with flavor, particularly the highly recommended CJ's Special.
For those seeking a cozy dining experience, CJ's Italian Restaurant offers a welcoming environment, where the friendly staff ensures each guest feels right at home. It’s an experience that goes beyond just food; it’s about community and connection, creating memories over shared plates of deliciousness.
So, if you find yourself on St Simons Island, make it a point to visit CJ's Italian Restaurant. Indulge in a slice of their delightful offerings and discover why this quaint spot has captured the hearts (and stomachs) of so many. Don't forget to try their desserts, just like Libby Gregory did, who noted that they couldn't resist enjoying them on-site!
For more information or to place an order, call them at +1 912-634-2711. Trust me, a visit to CJ's will surely leave you craving more!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Deep dish pizza is always delicious! This was our first time trying the dessert (we planned to take them home, hence the containers), they were delicious! They didn't make it home, we ate them right there! ”
“ Best pizza on the island. Plus great pastas salads and bread! ”
“ We moved to SSI recently so we’re going through the local restaurants little by little. Found this hole in the wall gem a couple of weeks ago. I haven’t had the pizza yet, but my wife has ordered the pasta both times. Kind of a build your own pasta type menu with their own specialties added in. I’ve had the CJs special sandwich both times. I highly recommend trying this on your first trip. I love it so much I haven’t tried anything else on their menu yet. It is a very small place so take out is the most ideal, especially if you have a big party. Update 7/28- had the deep dish “special”. I’m traditionally a thin crust guy, but man, their Detroit deep dish is where it’s at. ”
“ The cheese bread & deep dish pizza was amazing! Cute a cute little spot! Welcomed right when we walked in and waitresses were awesome as well! Even had a little helper who got us our drinks! ”
“ Quirky little pizza joint. And I mean little! Food was fabulous! I highly recommend the deep dish style for your pizza it is perfection! Airy, crunchy edges, absolutely perfect! We will definitely be back! ”
“ Excellent meal! We visited the Golden Isles the weekend after Independence Day 2023 and the kids wanted pizza on the last night. You would drive right by the place never knowing it was there and inside it is like an Athens, Ga college town restaurant: quaint and quirky! The cooks and owner all said Hello when we came in and our server was friendly. Our pizza was exactly how we ordered it and our drinks were refilled when needed! I would to try a calzone in the future when we return to this hidden in plain sight gem of a restaurant! ”
“ CJ’s Italian Restaurant instantly transported me back to my childhood, reminding me of my favorite local NJ pizzeria. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warm smiles and the friendliest staff who made us feel like family. The service was exceptional, and the food did not disappoint—everything was delicious and made with care. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or a full Italian meal, this place hits the mark. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a cozy atmosphere and great food! ”
“ Super cool place with absolutely top notch pizza. Get the deep dish with the crispy edges! Spaghetti and other dishes also fantastic. Service is by people who actually care about the restaurant and its reputation. Get the small pizza dough to play with for your kids. Great experience all around. Its a little small but maybe tha'ts just part of the deal. ”